Interrogative pronouns — qui que lequel

a four-cell table, and long forms that explain themselvesB1

In one line

Two questions decide which one you use: person or thing, and subject or object.

The forms on this page

FormMeansSound
quiwho — always for a person/ki/
quewhat — always for a thing/kə/
lequelwhich one — when choosing among several/lə.kɛl/

The table

subjectdirect objectafter a preposition
personqui /ki/qui /ki/qui /ki/
thingqu'est-ce qui /kɛs ki/que /kə/quoi /kwa/

And the long forms that match them:

subjectobject
personqui est-ce qui /ki ɛs ki/qui est-ce que /ki ɛs kə/
thingqu'est-ce qui /kɛs ki/qu'est-ce que /kɛs.kə/

How to read the long forms:

First part — qui = person · que = thing Last part — qui = subject · que = object

qui est-ce qui → person, subject · qu'est-ce que → thing, object

English asks both of the same questions, just never at the same time. Who versus what is the person/thing axis; who versus whom is the subject/object axis, and English has all but abandoned the second. French keeps both live, which is why one English "what" corresponds to two French forms — qu'est-ce qui when it is the subject, que when it is the object.

Four cells, four examples

RoleShortLongMeaning
person, subjectQui vient ? /ki vjɛ̃/Qui est-ce qui vient ? /ki ɛs ki vjɛ̃/who's coming?
person, objectQui vois-tu ? /ki vwa.ty/Qui est-ce que tu vois ? /ki ɛs kə ty vwa/who do you see?
thing, subject—Qu'est-ce qui se passe ? /kɛs ki sə pas/what's happening?
thing, objectQue fais-tu ? /kə fɛ ty/Qu'est-ce que tu fais ? /kɛs.kə ty fɛ/what are you doing?

The "thing, subject" cell has no short form. ❌ Que se passe ? — this is the one cell where you are obliged to use the long form.

Which means Qu'est-ce qui has to be learnt as a unit, since English "what's happening?" is as short as "what are you doing?" and gives no warning that the two need different French.

quoi — after a preposition and at the end

SituationExamplePronunciation
after a prepositionÀ quoi penses-tu ?
De quoi parles-tu ?
/a kwa pɑ̃s ty/ · /də kwa paʁl.ty/
at the end, colloquialTu fais quoi ?/ty fɛ kwa/
aloneQuoi ?/kwa/
in an exclamationQuoi ! Déjà ?/kwa/ · /de.ʒa/

que never comes after a preposition and never at the end of a sentence. In those positions it is quoi.

And note the word order: English puts the preposition at the end — "what are you thinking about?" — while French keeps it at the front: À quoi penses-tu ? Never Quoi penses-tu à ?

lequel — choosing among several

MasculineFeminine
singularlequel /lə.kɛl/laquelle /la.kɛl/
plurallesquels /le.kɛl/lesquelles /le.kɛl/

And contracting with à and de:

+ à+ de
masc. sing.auquel /o.kɛl/duquel /dy.kɛl/
fem. sing.à laquelle /a la.kɛl/de laquelle /də la.kɛl/
masc. pl.auxquels /o.kɛl/desquels /de.kɛl/
fem. pl.auxquelles /o.kɛl/desquelles /de.kɛl/

How it differs from quel:

RolePronunciation
Quel livre veux-tu ?adjective — with a noun/kɛl livʁ vø.ty/
Lequel veux-tu ?pronoun — instead of a noun/lə.kɛl vø ty/

English uses "which" for both — "which book?" and "which one?" — so the split has to be made deliberately: with a noun → quel; without one → lequel.

qui after a preposition — no long form needed

Pronunciation
À qui parles-tu ?who are you talking to?/a ki paʁl.ty/
Avec qui ?who with?/a.vɛk ki/
Pour qui ?who for?/puʁ ki/
De qui parles-tu ?who are you talking about?/də ki paʁl.ty/

A long form is possible but heavy: À qui est-ce que tu parles ?

Again, the preposition stays at the front in French. English strands it at the end — "who are you talking to?" — and French does not allow that anywhere.

In an indirect question the form changes

DirectIndirect
Qui vient ? /ki vjɛ̃/Je demande qui vient. /ʒə də.mɑ̃d ki vjɛ̃/
Qu'est-ce qui se passe ? /kɛs ki sə pas/Je demande ce qui se passe. /ʒə də.mɑ̃d sə ki sə pas/
Qu'est-ce que tu fais ? /kɛs.kə ty fɛ/Je demande ce que tu fais. /ʒə də.mɑ̃d sə kə ty fɛ/

qu'est-ce qui and qu'est-ce que become ce qui and ce que in an indirect question. The detail is in question-indirecte.

Examples

EnglishFrenchPronunciation
Who's coming?Qui vient ?/ki vjɛ̃/
Who did you see?Qui as-tu vu ?/ki a ty vy/
What happened?Qu'est-ce qui s'est passé ?/kɛs ki sɛ pa.se/
What are you doing?Que fais-tu ?/kə fɛ ty/
What are you doing? (casual)Tu fais quoi ?/ty fɛ kwa/
What are you thinking about?À quoi penses-tu ?/a kwa pɑ̃s ty/
Who are you talking to?Avec qui parles-tu ?/a.vɛk ki paʁl ty/
Which one do you want?Lequel veux-tu ?/lə.kɛl vø ty/
Which one are you thinking of?Auquel penses-tu ?/o.kɛl pɑ̃s ty/
Which ones are you talking about?Desquels parles-tu ?/de.kɛl paʁl ty/

Common mistakes

❌✅Why
Que se passe ?Qu'est-ce qui se passe ?The thing-subject cell has no short form
À que penses-tu ?À quoi penses-tu ?After a preposition it is quoi
Tu fais que ?Tu fais quoi ?At the end of a sentence it is quoi
Quel veux-tu ?Lequel veux-tu ?Without a noun you need the pronoun
À lequel ?Auquel ?The contraction is compulsory
Quoi penses-tu à ?À quoi penses-tu ?French never strands a preposition
Je demande qu'est-ce que tu fais.… ce que tu fais.The indirect form is different

Why the long forms were built

because the short forms were ambiguous

qui is both subject and object. In Qui vois-tu ? and Qui te voit ? it is the same word, and only the order distinguishes them.

And in speech, where inversion is avoided, that ambiguity becomes real.

So the language built a transparent structure: signal each part of the question separately.

Ambiguity
Qui voit Marie ? /ki vwa ma.ʁi/who sees Marie? or who does Marie see?
Qui est-ce qui voit Marie ? /ki ɛs ki vwa ma.ʁi/clear — the second qui /ki/ marks the subject
Qui est-ce que Marie voit ? /ki ɛs kə ma.ʁi vwa/clear — the que /kə/ marks the object

The price is length — four syllables instead of one. But it is perfectly acceptable in speech, and where ambiguity exists it is the natural choice.

English solved the identical problem with a different tool: it inserted "do" and kept the word order rigid — "who does Marie see?" versus "who sees Marie?". French has no "do", so it built a longer question word instead. Both languages added syllables; they just added them in different places.

The practical guidance for exams:

SectionWhat to usePronunciation
formal writingthe short form with inversion — Que fais-tu ?/kə fɛ ty/
speakingthe long form — Qu'est-ce que tu fais ?/kɛs.kə ty fɛ/
alwaysQu'est-ce qui for a thing-subject — there is no alternative/kɛs ki/

संबंधित