Speaking · task 34 min 30 · no preparationLevel B2

Is salary the most important thing in a job?

The task

4 min 30 · no preparation

Vous allez exprimer votre point de vue sur une question de société, sans préparation. Pendant environ quatre minutes et demie, vous parlez de façon spontanée et continue, et vous cherchez à convaincre l'examinateur.

Question : Pour vous, le salaire est-il le critère le plus important quand on choisit un emploi ? Partagez-vous cette opinion ? Expliquez pourquoi en vous appuyant sur des arguments et des exemples.

TCF Canada — expression orale — tâche 3

Translation of the prompt

You are going to express your point of view on a social issue, without preparation. For about four and a half minutes, you speak spontaneously and continuously, and you try to convince the examiner. Question: In your opinion, is salary the most important criterion when choosing a job? Do you share this opinion? Explain why, supporting yourself with arguments and examples.

How to structure your answer

  1. Open by rephrasing the question in your own words (20–30 seconds) and state a nuanced position right away: "le salaire est indispensable, mais je ne pense pas qu'il soit le plus important".

  2. First argument: salary meets concrete needs (housing, food, savings, sending money home). This is especially true for a newcomer to Canada. Give a concrete example.

  3. Second argument: other factors weigh as much, or even more, in the long term: atmosphere, work-life balance, mental health, sense of purpose, career progression, training. Use the example of someone who is well paid but exhausted.

  4. Third argument or counter-argument: a high salary does not always make up for excessive hours, stress or lack of recognition. Concede that priorities change at different stages of life ("En revanche, je reconnais que la réponse dépend de la situation de chacun").

  5. Conclude in about 30 seconds: sum up your position and widen to a general idea: the best job balances income, personal fulfilment and stability ("nécessaire mais pas suffisant").

  6. Throughout, keep talking for the full 4 minutes 30: develop personal examples and link your ideas with connectors such as "d'abord", "en outre", "cela dit", "en revanche", "pour conclure".

Model answer

about 453 words

Merci de me poser cette question, car c'est un sujet qui concerne presque tout le monde. Est-ce que le salaire est l'élément le plus important dans un travail ? Ma réponse est nuancée : le salaire est indispensable, mais je ne pense pas qu'il soit le plus important.

Commençons par reconnaître l'évidence : on travaille d'abord pour vivre. Un salaire décent permet de payer son loyer, de se nourrir, de se soigner et de penser à l'avenir. Cela est encore plus vrai pour une personne qui vient d'immigrer au Canada. Elle doit souvent payer un logement cher, rembourser des dépenses liées à l'installation et parfois soutenir sa famille restée au pays. Dans cette situation, un bon salaire n'est pas un luxe, c'est une condition de stabilité. Je comprends donc très bien ceux qui en font leur priorité.

Cela dit, je pense qu'au-delà d'un certain seuil, le salaire ne suffit plus. Prenons l'exemple d'un ami qui travaillait dans une banque à Montréal avec un excellent revenu. Il finissait tard chaque soir, n'avait presque pas de week-end et se sentait de plus en plus épuisé. Au bout de deux ans, il a accepté un poste moins bien payé, mais avec des horaires raisonnables et une équipe agréable. Il m'a dit qu'il n'avait jamais été aussi heureux. Cet exemple montre que l'équilibre entre vie professionnelle et vie privée a une valeur que l'argent n'achète pas.

De plus, il y a la question de l'évolution. Un emploi qui offre de la formation, de la reconnaissance et des perspectives de promotion peut rapporter beaucoup plus à long terme qu'un poste bien payé mais sans avenir. Un jeune diplômé a souvent intérêt à choisir une entreprise où il apprend, même si le salaire de départ est modeste, parce que ses compétences augmenteront sa valeur sur le marché.

Il faut aussi parler du sens du travail. Un infirmier, un enseignant ou un travailleur communautaire gagnent parfois moins que d'autres professionnels, mais ils ressentent que leur métier est utile. Cette satisfaction est un moteur puissant, qui protège contre l'usure et le découragement.

En revanche, je reconnais que la réponse dépend de la situation de chacun. Quand on a des dettes ou des enfants à charge, le salaire passe naturellement au premier plan. Plus tard, quand les besoins de base sont couverts, d'autres critères prennent le dessus : le bien-être, l'autonomie, l'ambiance.

Pour conclure, je dirais que le salaire est une condition nécessaire mais pas suffisante. Le meilleur emploi n'est pas forcément le mieux payé, c'est celui qui offre un équilibre entre un revenu convenable, des conditions de travail saines et des perspectives d'avenir. C'est pourquoi je ne partage pas tout à fait l'idée que le salaire soit l'élément le plus important.

Show the translation

Thank you for asking me this question, because it is a subject that concerns almost everyone. Is salary the most important element in a job? My answer is nuanced: salary is essential, but I do not think it is the most important thing.

Let us start by acknowledging the obvious: we work first of all in order to live. A decent salary lets you pay your rent, feed yourself, get medical care and think about the future. This is even truer for someone who has just immigrated to Canada. They often have to pay for expensive housing, repay expenses linked to settling in and sometimes support their family who stayed back home. In this situation, a good salary is not a luxury; it is a condition of stability. So I understand very well those who make it their priority.

That said, I think that beyond a certain threshold, salary is no longer enough. Take the example of a friend who worked in a bank in Montreal with an excellent income. He finished late every evening, had almost no weekends and felt more and more exhausted. After two years, he accepted a less well-paid position, but with reasonable hours and a pleasant team. He told me he had never been so happy. This example shows that the balance between professional and private life has a value that money cannot buy.

In addition, there is the question of career development. A job that offers training, recognition and prospects of promotion can bring in much more in the long term than a well-paid position with no future. A young graduate often has an interest in choosing a company where they learn, even if the starting salary is modest, because their skills will increase their value on the market.

We must also talk about the meaning of work. A nurse, a teacher or a community worker sometimes earn less than other professionals, but they feel that their profession is useful. This satisfaction is a powerful driving force, which protects against wear and tear and discouragement.

On the other hand, I acknowledge that the answer depends on each person's situation. When you have debts or dependent children, salary naturally comes first. Later, when basic needs are covered, other criteria take over: well-being, autonomy, atmosphere.

To conclude, I would say that salary is a necessary but not sufficient condition. The best job is not necessarily the best paid; it is the one that offers a balance between a decent income, healthy working conditions and future prospects. That is why I do not entirely share the idea that salary is the most important element.

Key vocabulary

Word or phraseMeaning
la rémunérationwhat you receive in return for your work (salary, bonuses, benefits)
l'équilibre travail-vie personnellework-life balance: being able to combine your job with your private life
l'épanouissement professionnelprofessional fulfilment: feeling that you are growing and are happy in your career
les avantages sociauxemployee benefits: insurance, leave and a pension plan provided by the employer on top of the salary
le burn-out (l'épuisement professionnel)burnout: extreme exhaustion caused by work
les perspectives d'évolutioncareer prospects: opportunities for promotion and advancement within the company
la conciliation travail-famillework-family balance: an arrangement that lets you look after your family while working
la reconnaissancerecognition: your work being valued by your superiors and colleagues
un seuil de confortcomfort threshold: the income level at which you cover your needs without difficulty
nécessaire mais pas suffisantnecessary but not sufficient: used to say a condition is essential but does not solve everything

Common mistakes

  • Wrong comparative/superlative structure. Say "plus important que tout" (more important than everything) or "le plus important de tous les critères" (the most important of all criteria); do not mix "le plus" with "que tout".

    Wrongle salaire est le plus important que tout

    Rightle salaire est plus important que tout

  • Vocabulary confusion: do not mix up "salaire" with "salaire net/brut", and use the correct spelling "paiement" (not "payement"). Also remember that "rémunération" is the broader word, covering salary plus bonuses and benefits.

    Wrongle payement de mon salaire

    Rightle paiement de ma rémunération

  • Gender error: "avis" is masculine, so the demonstrative is "cet" (before a vowel), not "cette".

    Wrongje suis d'accord avec cette avis

    Rightje suis d'accord avec cet avis

  • "Malgré que" with the subjunctive is considered incorrect or too informal for the exam; prefer "bien que" (+ subjunctive) or "même si" (+ indicative).

    Wrongmalgré qu'il soit bien payé

    Rightbien qu'il soit bien payé

  • Speaking too fast and stringing ideas together without connectors makes your talk hard to follow. Use "d'abord", "en outre", "cela dit", "en revanche", "pour conclure".

  • Staying too short or repeating the same idea. You need to fill the full 4 minutes 30 with developed personal examples.

  • Wrong word choice: use "trouver un emploi" (or "un poste") rather than "avoir un travail" in this sense, and do not pluralise "travail" in the meaning of 'job'; use "les emplois" or "les postes" ("travail" is generally singular in this sense).

    Wrongil a eu un travail ; les travails

    Rightil a trouvé un emploi ; les emplois / les postes

  • Spelling/pronunciation: the word is "ambiance", not "ambience". Also, do not use "opportunité" in every context; "occasion" or "possibilité" is often more appropriate.

    Wrongune bonne ambience ; une opportunité de sortir

    Rightune bonne ambiance ; une occasion de sortir

The grammar this task needs

Expressing concession and contrast (bien que + subjunctive, même si + indicative, cela dit, en revanche)

The task asks you to take a nuanced position: salary matters, but it is not the most important thing. You need to concede a point and then push back, and this is how you do it smoothly. Note that 'malgré que' is a common error; use 'bien que' or 'même si' instead.

  • Bien que le salaire soit important, il ne suffit pas à rendre un travail agréable.
  • Même si le salaire est élevé, on peut se sentir épuisé.
  • Cela dit, quand on a des enfants à charge, le salaire passe au premier plan.
  • Un poste bien payé n'est pas toujours le meilleur ; en revanche, un poste épanouissant peut compenser un salaire modeste.

Comparatives and superlatives (plus important que, le plus important de)

The question itself is a superlative ('le critère le plus important'). Candidates often mix up the structures, such as 'le plus important que tout'. You must compare criteria correctly: salary versus work-life balance, recognition and so on.

  • Le salaire n'est pas le critère le plus important de tous.
  • L'équilibre de vie compte parfois plus que l'argent.
  • Pour un jeune diplômé, la formation est aussi importante que le salaire de départ.
  • Cet emploi est moins bien payé, mais il est bien plus intéressant.

Conditional and hypothesis with si (si + present → future / si + imperfect → conditional)

To make your arguments convincing you need to imagine situations: what would happen if someone chose only for money. It also lets you present your personal opinion politely ('je dirais que...').

  • Si on choisit un emploi uniquement pour le salaire, on risque de s'épuiser.
  • Si j'avais le choix, je préférerais un poste moins payé mais avec de bons horaires.
  • Je dirais que le salaire est nécessaire mais pas suffisant.
  • Si mon ami n'avait pas changé de poste, il aurait peut-être fait un burn-out.

Gender and agreement of common nouns (cet avis, un emploi, des emplois)

The page lists typical errors: 'cette avis', 'les travails'. Examiners notice basic agreement mistakes, especially on words you use constantly in this topic.

  • Je partage cet avis.
  • Il a trouvé un emploi dans une banque.
  • Les emplois les mieux payés ne sont pas toujours les plus épanouissants.
  • C'est un sujet qui concerne presque tout le monde.

Phrases to reuse

PhraseWhen to use it
Ma réponse est nuancée : ... mais ...In your introduction, to state your position clearly: you accept one point but defend another.
Commençons par reconnaître l'évidence : ...To open your first argument by conceding the obvious (people work in order to live) before developing your own view.
Cela dit, je pense qu'au-delà d'un certain seuil, ...To pivot from a concession to your main argument.
Prenons l'exemple de + nomTo introduce a concrete example, which the examiner expects for every argument.
Cet exemple montre que + indicatifTo draw a conclusion from your example, so it doesn't just sit there as a story.
De plus, il y a la question de + nomTo add a new argument and keep your talk moving.
Il faut aussi parler de + nomTo add another point (here, the meaning of work) without repeating a connector.
En revanche, je reconnais que + indicatifTo introduce a counter-argument or a concession near the end of your talk.
Cela dépend de la situation de chacun.To nuance your view: priorities change with life stage, family situation and so on.
nécessaire mais pas suffisantA compact formula to summarise your position on salary, perfect for the conclusion.
Pour conclure, je dirais que + indicatifTo signal the conclusion and sum up your position.
C'est pourquoi je ne partage pas tout à fait l'idée que + subjonctifTo restate your opinion at the very end; note the subjunctive after a negative verb of opinion.

Ideas bank

PositionArgumentExample
For (salary matters)Salary covers basic needs: housing, food, health care, savings.In a city like Montréal or Toronto where rents are high, a low salary creates daily stress, whatever the job is like.
For (salary matters)For a newcomer to Canada, income is a condition of stability.A new immigrant has to pay installation costs and may send money to family back home, so the first job is often chosen for pay.
For (salary matters)With debts or dependent children, salary naturally comes first.A parent with a mortgage and two children cannot easily accept a lower-paid but more 'fulfilling' job.
Against (salary is not the most important)Work-life balance has a value money cannot buy.A friend left a very well-paid banking job with endless evenings for a lower-paid one with reasonable hours and said he had never been happier.
Against (salary is not the most important)Training, recognition and career prospects can bring more in the long run.A young graduate who joins a company where they learn a lot will have more market value in five years than someone in a well-paid dead-end job.
Against (salary is not the most important)Meaning at work protects against wear and discouragement.Nurses, teachers and community workers often earn less but feel their job is useful, which keeps them motivated.
Against (salary is not the most important)A high salary does not compensate for stress, excessive hours or lack of recognition.Someone earning a lot but who is exhausted and gets no thanks risks a burn-out and may end up paying in health costs.
NuancePriorities change with the stage of life.At the start of a career or when settling in a new country, pay comes first; later, once basic needs are covered, well-being and autonomy take over.
NuanceSalary is a necessary but not sufficient condition; the ideal job balances income, fulfilment and stability.Use this as your conclusion: the best job is not necessarily the best paid, but the one that offers a decent income, healthy conditions and a future.
NuanceBenefits beyond the salary count as part of the total pay.Health insurance, paid leave and a pension plan can be worth more than a slightly higher hourly rate.

What the examiner looks for

The examiner wants to hear a clear position from the first 30 seconds (here: salary is important but not the most important), then sustained speech for the full 4 minutes 30 without long silences. Each argument should come with a developed, concrete example, ideally personal, rather than a list of abstract ideas. Linking words (d'abord, de plus, cela dit, en revanche, pour conclure) show that your talk is organised, and conceding a counter-argument shows maturity of thought. At B2/C1 level, accurate grammar (subjunctive after 'bien que', agreement, correct use of 'emploi' vs 'travail') and varied vocabulary (rémunération, épanouissement, équilibre, reconnaissance) make the difference.

More questions · workUnderstanding the examTake the free TCF Canada practice test