Homophones — a or à?

the largest single source of errors in written examsA2

In one line

These pairs sound identical and mean different things. In speech they make no difference; in writing they cost marks.

English has exactly this problem, and English speakers already know it is a real one. There / their / they're, its / it's, your / you're, to / too / two — same sound, different spelling, and getting it wrong marks the writer. French homophones are the same kind of error, and French readers judge them the same way. The good news is that French gives you a mechanical test for most of them, which English does not.

The forms on this page

FormMeansSound
ahas — third person of avoir/a/
àto · at — a preposition. It sounds identical to a/a/

The table

PairWhich means whatThe test
a /a/ / à /a/a /a/ is a verb (avoir /a.vwaʁ/)
à /a/ is a preposition
substitute avait /a.vɛ/ — does it work? → a /a/
ou /u/ / où /u/ou /u/ is "or"
où /u/ is "where"
substitute "or" — does it work? → ou /u/
et /e/ / est /ɛ/et /e/ is "and"
est /ɛ/ is a verb
substitute "and" — does it work? → et /e/
son /sɔ̃/ / sont /sɔ̃/son /sɔ̃/ is a possessive
sont /sɔ̃/ is a verb
substitute étaient /e.tɛ/ — does it work? → sont /sɔ̃/
on /ɔ̃/ / ont /ɔ̃/on /ɔ̃/ is a pronoun
ont /ɔ̃/ is a verb
substitute avaient /a.vɛ/ — does it work? → ont /ɔ̃/
ce /sə/ / se /sə/ce /sə/ is a demonstrative
se /sə/ is reflexive
is a verb next? → se /sə/
ces /se/ / ses /se/ces /se/ is "these"
ses /se/ is "his/her"
does "his/her" work? → ses /se/
la /la/ / là /la/la /la/ is an article
là /la/ means "there"
is a noun next? → la /la/
peu /pø/ / peut /pø/peu /pø/ is "little"
peut /pø/ is a verb
substitute pouvait /pu.vɛ/ — does it work? → peut /pø/
mais /mɛ/ / mes /me/mais /mɛ/ is "but"
mes /me/ is a possessive
does "but" work? → mais /mɛ/
sa /sa/ / ça /sa/sa /sa/ is a possessive
ça /sa/ means "that"
is a noun next? → sa /sa/
quand /kɑ̃/ / quant /kɑ̃/quand /kɑ̃/ is "when"
quant à /kɑ̃.t‿a/ is "as for"
quant /kɑ̃/ always comes with à /a/
si /si/ / s'y /si/si /si/ is "if"
s'y /si/ = se /sə/ + y /i/
is a verb next? → s'y /si/
dans /dɑ̃/ / d'en /dɑ̃/dans /dɑ̃/ is "in"
d'en /dɑ̃/ = de /də/ + en /ɑ̃/
is a noun next? → dans /dɑ̃/

The golden test — change the tense

Any pair where one member is a verb is solved by this one move:

Put the sentence in the past. If that word changes too, it was a verb.

SentenceIn the pastSo
Il a un livre. /i.l‿a œ̃ livʁ/Il avait un livre. /il a.vɛ.t‿œ̃ livʁ/a verb → a /a/
Il va à Paris. /il va a pa.ʁi/Il allait à Paris. /il a.lɛ.t‿a pa.ʁi/unchanged → à /a/
Ils sont là. /il sɔ̃ la/Ils étaient là. /ilz e.tɛ la/a verb → sont /sɔ̃/
Son livre. /sɔ̃ livʁ/Son livre. /sɔ̃ livʁ/unchanged → son /sɔ̃/

You already use this method in English. To choose between its and it's, you expand to "it is" and see whether the sentence survives. The French test is the same manoeuvre with a different substitution — and unlike the English one, it covers seven pairs instead of one.

Exceptions

NoteWhat happens
à /a/ is never a verbif you are unsure and the slot needs a verb, it is a /a/
où /u/ is the only word with ù /y/in the whole of French, only this one
c'est /sɛ/ and s'est /sɛ/c'est /sɛ/ = "it is"
s'est /sɛ/ = a reflexive in the past: il s'est lavé /il sɛ la.ve/
ce /sə/ can precede a verb tooce sont /sə sɔ̃/
ce serait /sə sə.ʁɛ/ — so the "is a verb next" test is not sufficient on its own
leur /lœʁ/ / leurs /lœʁ/the object pronoun never takes an s /ɛs/: je leur parle /ʒə lœʁ paʁl/; the possessive does: leurs livres /lœʁ livʁ/

Examples

EnglishFrenchPronunciation
He has a bookIl a un livre./i.l‿a œ̃ livʁ/
He's going to ParisIl va à Paris./il va a pa.ʁi/
Tea or coffee?Thé ou café ?/te u ka.fe/
Where do you live?Où habites-tu ?/u a.bit ty/
my father and my mothermon père et ma mère/mɔ̃ pɛʁ e ma mɛʁ/
He is happyIl est content./i.l‿ɛ kɔ̃.tɑ̃/
his bookson livre/sɔ̃ livʁ/
They are hereIls sont ici./il sɔ̃.t‿i.si/

Common mistakes

❌✅Why
Il à un livre.Il a un livre.avait works → it is a verb
Il va a Paris.Il va à Paris.It is a preposition and needs the accent
Ou habites-tu ?Où habites-tu ?"Where" carries the accent
Ils son là.Ils sont là.étaient works → it is a verb
Ce lave.Se lave.It is a reflexive pronoun
Je leurs parle.Je leur parle.The object pronoun takes no s

Why this matters so much

irrelevant in speech, decisive in writing

Every pair in the table is pronounced identically:

IPA
a
à
/a/
ou
où
/u/
et
est
/e/ · /ɛ/ — a fine difference that disappears in speech
son
sont
/sɔ̃/
ce
se
/sə/

So when you speak, nobody can tell which one you had in mind. When you write, each one is a spelling error.

And these are among the most frequent words in the language — a, à, et, est appear in almost every sentence. One bad habit produces dozens of errors in a single text.

The practical advice: drill the "put it in the past" test until it is automatic. Seven of the twelve pairs in this table are solved by that one move.

संबंधित